Stop Discounting Your Way to a Dead Black Friday: Keep Your Profits with Gift Cards, Rewards & Rebates!
Here’s how to break free from the discount treadmill, keep your margins & play the long game!
“Oh my God, check that out. Look at it! It’s a free gift card.”
That’s how you should want your customer to feel when they hit your Black Friday offer. Excited. Shocked. Hooked. Not yawning over the same recycled “20% OFF EVERYTHING” banner that every other brand is vomiting out like a discount junkie.
If you’re running an ecommerce brand, let me hit you with some math:
You run 20% off sitewide.
Your margins are already slim—maybe 30-40%.
Boom, you just nuked half your profit.
Congrats, you worked harder for less money.
Meanwhile, the brands that actually keep their margins don’t play that game. They don’t discount themselves into oblivion. They use smarter offers—offers that drive sales and loyalty, not margin suicide. And the three most profitable levers?
Gift Cards
Points & Rewards
Rebates / Cash Back Offers
Let’s break each down and show you how to run Black Friday like a capitalist, not a coupon clipper.
The Problem with Discounts
Here’s the uncomfortable truth: 20% off is lazy marketing.
It says:
“We don’t know how else to get you to buy.”
“We don’t care about future purchases.”
“We’re fine trading long-term profit for a short-term sugar high.”
And it works—sort of. Sure, you’ll spike sales on Black Friday. But come December 1st, what do you have?
A customer base trained to wait for discounts.
A smaller margin pool to reinvest into ads, product, or fulfillment.
Zero long-term loyalty.
Meanwhile, the big dogs—the ones growing past 8 and 9 figures—don’t discount like you think they do. They’ve figured out a way to win twice: make the sale today, guarantee another tomorrow.
Strategy #1: Gift Cards (The Profit Multiplier)
Instead of giving $100 off a $500 product, give a $25 or $50 gift card.
Why?
You protect your margin.
With a discount, your AOV drops instantly.
With a gift card, your revenue today stays the same.
You lock in a second purchase.
A discount is one-and-done.
A gift card guarantees a future order.
You create a loyalty loop.
That card is redeemable only at your store.
You just converted a one-time buyer into a repeat buyer.
Example:
A customer buys $500 headphones.
Discount route: 20% off → $400 collected → you lose $100 margin.
Gift card route: Sell at $500, include a $50 gift card → you keep margin today, and you guarantee they’ll come back.
Even better: some gift cards never get used. That’s called breakage. And it’s free margin.
Industry averages?
$5 and $10 cards often get lost or forgotten.
$25 and $50 cards get redeemed more, but even then, not 100%.
So even when you give away value, you don’t always lose it.
Tactical Twist:
Delay the gift card. Issue it after 30 days. Why? It slashes returns. Customers can’t buy, return, and still pocket the gift card. You protect yourself from fraud while rewarding legit buyers.
Strategy #2: Points & Rewards (LTV Rocket Fuel)
Discounts kill LTV (lifetime value). Rewards build it.
Think about it: Starbucks didn’t become a trillion-dollar caffeine dealer by handing out “20% off lattes.” They built a reward system so addictive it feels like a game. Buy coffee, earn stars, redeem later. Customers line up not just for coffee but for points.
Your brand can do the same.
How It Works:
Instead of 20% off, offer “5X points on Black Friday purchases.”
Customer spends $200, earns 1,000 points (worth $10-$20 in future credit).
They come back to redeem, often spending more than the credit’s worth.
Why It Wins:
Keeps margins intact. The customer pays full price today.
Guarantees repeat purchase. Points have to be redeemed.
Gamifies loyalty. People love collecting, hoarding, and redeeming.
Rewards don’t just make a sale—they build a relationship. And unlike discounts, rewards compound. The more points someone earns, the harder it is to switch to another brand.
Strategy #3: Rebates & Cash Back (Psychology Hack)
Rebates sound like discounts, but they’re not.
The difference? Timing.
Discounts are instant.
Rebates are delayed.
This single tweak changes the psychology of the purchase and the economics for you.
Example:
Instead of “20% off today,” try:
“Spend $200, get $25 cash back after 30 days.”
Or “Buy now, claim a $50 rebate gift card.”
Why It Works:
Protects margins upfront. Customer pays full price today.
Prevents returns. If they want the rebate, they need to keep the product.
Drives retention. Rebates often come in the form of store credit or gift cards, which means—again—they come back.
Rebates let you play the same game as discounts while keeping your cash flow intact. You’re not losing money upfront. You’re investing in a future purchase.
The Math Behind the Madness
Let’s make this concrete.
Say you sell a $100 product. Your margin is 40%.
Discount Route (20% Off):
Customer pays $80.
Your margin is $40 → you keep $32.
One sale. Done.
Gift Card Route ($20 Gift Card):
Customer pays $100.
You keep $40 margin.
Later, they redeem $20 gift card.
They spend another $60+ (most customers spend more than the gift card).
That’s $24 more margin, minimum.
End result: instead of $32, you pocket $64+. Double.
This is why smart brands scale. They make money twice on the same customer.
Objection: “But My Customers Want Discounts!”
No, they want value. And value doesn’t equal discounts.
Think about it: If someone buys a $500 product and gets a $50 gift card, do they complain? No. They brag. They feel like they got a bonus.
It’s framing. Discounts subtract value. Gift cards, points, and rebates add value. One makes you smaller. The other makes you bigger.
Implementation Playbook (Do This Before Black Friday)
Don’t wing this on Q4 weekend. Set it up now. Here’s how:
Pick Your Weapon.
Want repeat purchases? Gift cards.
Want loyalty compounding? Rewards.
Want cash flow now, retention later? Rebates.
Create Tiers.
$5 gift card for orders $50+.
$20 for orders $150+.
$50 for orders $500+.
Tiering nudges customers to spend more to unlock higher perks.
Test Early.
Run A/B campaigns in October.
Test gift card vs discount performance.
Optimize messaging.
Market It Differently.
Don’t say “sale.” Say “bonus.”
Don’t say “discount.” Say “reward.”
Example headline: “Buy Now, Get Paid Later.”
Delay Delivery.
For gift cards and rebates, issue after 30 days.
This kills returns and abuse.
Track Redemption.
Know your breakage rate.
Adjust offers accordingly.
Real Talk: Why Most Brands Won’t Do This
Most brands will keep handing out 20% off like free candy. Why?
It’s easy.
It’s safe.
It’s what everyone else does.
But that’s why they stay stuck at 6 or 7 figures. They optimize for today’s dopamine hit, not tomorrow’s bank account.
If you’re reading this, you already know better. You don’t need to play the discount death spiral. You can make more, keep more, and scale faster—by structuring offers that build equity in your customer base.
Closing
This Black Friday, you have two options:
Join the discount graveyard. Burn your margins. Pray you survive Q4.
Or build like the billion-dollar brands. Use gift cards, rewards, and rebates to:
Keep profits.
Drive loyalty.
Lock in repeat sales.
Don’t just run a sale. Run a strategy.
Break free from the discount treadmill. Keep your margins. Play the long game.
l.
If your email revenue is down this month, you’re not sleeping well. You’ve got payroll, ad bills, inventory costs, and maybe investors breathing down your neck. And you’re sitting there thinking: “If we don’t hit our revenue goal this month, we’re screwed.”
I’ve been there. And if I had to save my month—fast—this is the exact play I’d run. No fluff. No “cute” branding. No overpaid copywriter writing you a Shakespearean sonnet. Just a strategy that makes you money right now.
This is the emergency email that gets you revenue on the board before the month ends. Let’s break it down.
Step 1: Fire the Fancy Stuff
Here’s the harsh truth: the expensive designer or copywriter you’re calling in for a last-minute “hail mary” is the same person (or team) who built the bloated campaigns that failed you in the first place.
They’re going to charge you thousands of dollars for a rushed design. And the end product? Pretty. But useless.
You don’t need pretty. You don’t need clever.
You need cash in the bank.
What you need is a strategist. Someone who knows how to take what you’ve already got (your subscribers, your product catalog, your data) and squeeze the juice out of it.
So forget fancy. Forget “brand-perfect.” Forget “award-winning creative.” Your customer doesn’t care. They care about value, relevance, and why they should buy today.
Step 2: Build Four Segments That Print Money
Most brands send the same email to everyone. That’s why their results suck. Segmentation is the money-maker here.
You don’t need 10 segments, 20 flows, or a million “if/then” branches. You need four simple segments:
Browsers: People who’ve been on your site, clicked around, but didn’t buy.
Cart Abandoners: People who put something in their cart but ghosted.
Engaged Subscribers: People who open your emails but haven’t bought recently.
Super Engaged Subscribers: People who open everything and are basically begging for a reason to buy.
That’s it. These four groups cover 80% of the opportunity sitting in your list right now.
When you target these groups specifically, you stop wasting effort on people who don’t care. You focus your energy on the people closest to giving you money.
Step 3: Ditch the Design, Use Canva Instead
I already told you—fire the designer. Open Canva. Create a simple banner.
Something like:
“Styles You’ll Love”
“Treat Yourself to These”
“We Saw These and Thought of You.”
You don’t need pixel-perfect graphics. You need something that catches attention and connects on a human level.
And here’s the pro move: make multiple banners and keep them on file. Every time you hit a slump month, you’ve got a folder of emergency lifelines ready to drop in.
Step 4: Dynamic Emails That Actually Sell
Here’s where most brands blow it. They think the email is about them. It’s not. It’s about the customer.
Go into Klaviyo (or whatever ESP you’re using). Create a new email template. Put your simple Canva banner at the top.
Underneath? Dynamic product feeds.
Meaning every subscriber sees products relevant to them.
To the cart abandoner—it’s the thing they left behind.
To the browser—it’s the item they viewed.
To the engaged subscriber—it’s the trending bestseller.
To the super engaged—it’s the product they’re most likely to drool over.
Now here’s the magic: every email looks different because it’s personalized to the segment. Suddenly, your “one email” becomes four hyper-relevant campaigns without four times the work.
Step 5 (Optional): Add an Exclusive Offer
You don’t always need a discount. But if you want to crank urgency, add an exclusive perk:
Free shipping until end of month.
Bonus gift for you.
% OFF or $$ OFF if you want.
Make it clear this isn’t a “sitewide” free-for-all. It’s tailored to them. And make it expire before the month ends—because we’re solving an immediate problem here.
Step 6: Subject Lines That Get Opened
This is where most brands go soft. They write subject lines like:
“End of Month Sale!”
“20% Off Just for You!”
Boring. Predictable. Ignored.
You want personalization. Intrigue. Curiosity. A reason to click. Examples:
“Isaac, treat yourself to these!”
“Exclusively for Isaac!”
“Isaac, want to reward yourself after a long week?”
“Isaac, an end of month gift from us to you…”
Pair it with preview text that sets the hook:
“Let’s keep this between us.”
“Saw these and thought of you.”
“Styles you’ve liked at a new price you’ll LOVE”
When your subject line + preview text combo sparks curiosity and urgency, your open rates double. Which means more eyeballs. Which means more clicks. Which means more sales.
Step 7: Hit Send & Watch It Work
At this point, stop overthinking. You’ve got:
Four killer segments.
Simple Canva banners.
Dynamic product feeds.
An optional exclusive offer.
Subject lines that punch.
Now hit send. Don’t wait for a “perfect” time. Don’t ask for 15 rounds of approvals. Don’t overanalyze.
Your open rates will climb. Your clicks will follow. Your conversions will triple compared to your last “fancy” campaign.
That’s how you turn a down month into a strong finish—without relying on copywriters, designers, or some magic paid ad campaign.
Why This Works
Segmentation + Personalization.
That’s it.
You don’t need 1,000 tactics. You don’t need a 20-step funnel. You don’t need a million-dollar budget. You need to hit the right people with the right message at the right time.
Most brands send one message to everyone and wonder why no one buys. This strategy flips that. It gets hyper-relevant fast.
It’s not pretty. It’s not fancy. It’s effective. And effective is what pays your bills.
The Conversation You Don’t Want to Have
Let’s be honest: if you’re in this situation, the emergency email will save your month. But the real problem?
Your paid ads and social teams aren’t crushing it. Your brand’s not building enough momentum outside of email.
Email and SMS are safety nets. They keep you from crashing when your other channels stumble. But if you’re relying on this emergency play every month, you don’t have a growth problem—you’ve got a strategy problem.
That’s when you need to talk to an agency (like mine) that knows how to make sure you don’t hit down months in the first place.
Final Word
If you take nothing else from this, remember:
Stop wasting money on “pretty.”
Build four simple segments.
Use dynamic product feeds.
Write subject lines that intrigue.
Hit send and watch the money come in.
That’s how you send the one emergency email that saves your month.
Now – screenshot this, save it, tattoo it on your arm. Because the next time your revenue’s down, this playbook is how you make ends meet without panicking.
And if you’re sick of scrambling at the end of every month? Talk to us. We’ll make sure you don’t just survive the month—you dominate it.
👉 Need help implementing a smarter Q4 & BFCM plan?
Take action now:
Book a Free Email & SMS Audit & Discover The True Revenue Potential of Your List >
Loved this blog post? Take one of these next steps: