The Perfect Black Friday Email Template That Doubles Clicks & Sales! | Retention Nation Podcast
Most brands treat Black Friday like a fire sale.
They carpet-bomb their list with more emails, bigger fonts, louder GIFs, and 70% OFF slapped everywhere like duct tape on a leaking pipe… then wonder why their click rates tank and their Klaviyo bill goes up.
The truth?
You don’t have a sending problem. You have a template problem.
This episode of Retention Nation breaks down a simple truth:
If your Black Friday email templates are built for you and not for your customer, you’re leaving serious money on the table.
Let’s turn that into a clear, actionable playbook you can actually use.
Black Friday Isn’t a “Sale” — It’s a Traffic War
For five days — from Thanksgiving through Cyber Monday — your customers are getting punched in the inbox from every angle.
Hundreds of brands.
Hundreds of offers.
Hundreds of “LAST CHANCE” subject lines.
In that chaos, your only job with email is:
Drive qualified traffic to your store, and
Do it in a way that gives you data to personalize the next message.
That’s it.
Email is a traffic generator.
Your ads, your affiliates, your influencers, your SMS — they’re all doing the same thing: pushing humans to the place where money changes hands.
So if your Black Friday “strategy” is:
“Let’s send more emails and hope something hits.”
…you’ve already lost.
Instead, you need fewer emails, better email design, and a template structure that multiplies clicks, not just shouts louder.
The Real Goal of Email Design on Black Friday
Most founders and marketers obsess over:
Pretty layouts
Clever copy
Fancy animations
“On-brand” aesthetics
Those things are fine. But they’re a side quest.
The primary goal of email design — especially on Black Friday — is this:
Get as many relevant clicks from the right people as possible.
Because clicks = data.
And data = personalization.
And personalization = more revenue per send.
If someone clicks “Wall Art” in your Wayfair email, that’s not just a click. That’s a signal. Your very next email should look like this:
“Cool, you like wall art? Here’s the best wall art for Black Friday.”
That’s how the top brands — the retailers with 100,000+ SKUs — win. They don’t just send pretty emails. They send responsive emails. The email changes based on what you told them last time with your click.
If your email templates don’t create those click points, you’re flying blind.
The C-Four Playbook: How Smart Brands Think About Email Design
Most people think “design” means colors and fonts.
That’s amateur hour.
Top-performing Black Friday email design follows a simple four-pillar framework — what Isaac calls the C-Four Playbook:
Context
Creatives
Customer
Conversion
Let’s break it down.
1. Context: Why Are You Sending This?
Every email must answer one question first:
“What is this email supposed to do?”
Is it:
Driving early access?
Announcing the main Black Friday deal?
Pushing a last-chance offer?
Showing curated picks?
If the context is vague, the email feels like noise. Your template has to reflect the purpose of the message — not just “Black Friday vibes.”
2. Creatives: Yes, Make It Look Good… But With a Job
Creatives = your visuals: hero images, banners, product shots.
Bad brands design to impress themselves.
Good brands design with a job description:
This hero image must grab attention and communicate the deal in 1–2 seconds.
This banner must reinforce value (free shipping, free returns, etc.).
This product block must make it obvious what to click next.
If a block doesn’t push the customer forward in the journey, it’s decoration, not design.
3. Customer: Personalization or Bust
Here’s the punchline:
Without personalization, your design doesn’t matter. You might as well send a flyer.
If the customer doesn’t see themselves in the email, they don’t click.
No click = no data.
No data = no smarter next email.
Your Black Friday email templates should be built so that:
Different categories are visible (men, women, kids, home, tech, etc.)
Different product types are clickable (bundles, accessories, bestsellers)
Dynamic products can slot in based on what they’ve browsed or bought
The more click options that are relevant, the higher the click-rate. Not because you “designed better,” but because you listened better.
4. Conversion: Where Does Each Click Take Them?
Your linking strategy is part of your email design.
Driving everything to the homepage is lazy and expensive.
No segmentation, no clear intent, no data.
Instead:
Hero → Landing page or collection
Product image → PDP (product detail page)
Navigation → Specific categories
Value banners → Gift guide, FAQs, shipping policies, financing, etc.
Each link should say: “If they click here, what do we now know about them, and what’s the next message?”
That’s email design as a system, not as art.
The 3 Phases of Black Friday Customer Psychology
Most email marketers write like every subscriber is in the same headspace. They aren’t.
On Black Friday, customers move through three mental phases:
Curiosity
Curated
Click
And your email templates need to map directly to each phase.
Phase 1: Curiosity – “What’s Out There?”
This is the morning of Black Friday (or even earlier).
Your customer is asking:
What’s on sale?
Who has the best deal?
What do I actually need — clothes, gifts, tech, home stuff?
Is this site-wide or just certain things?
They’re not loyal. They’re scanning.
They’re jumping from Macy’s to Nordstrom to Zara to your brand.
Your job in this phase:
Help them explore in a structured way.
That means your email template must:
Show the main offer clearly (hero image)
Expose key categories (navigation)
Sprinkle in dynamic products as “hooks”
Reinforce value props (banners/footer)
We’ll break that structure down in a second.
Phase 2: Curated – “I Know What I Want”
Now they’ve narrowed it down:
“I need shirts.”
“I need boots.”
“I need wall art.”
“I need gifts for kids under $50.”
In this phase, they’re asking:
Is this brand the right place to buy from?
Do they have my size? My color? My price point?
Will it arrive in time?
Your email now has to curate, not just shout.
You’re putting the right offers, categories, and products in front of them based on what they’ve already clicked.
This is where dynamic email templates and personalization pay off. You’re saying:
“You showed interest in X. Here are the best X deals just for you.”
Phase 3: Click – “I’m Almost There… Push Me”
These people already know:
What they want
That you have it
That the deal is good
They just haven’t pulled the trigger yet.
Why?
They’re waiting to get to a desktop
They want to check with a spouse
They got distracted
They’re procrastinating
This is where your last chance style template comes in — short, tight, and focused on one job:
“Get back on the site and finish.”
The psychology here is urgency, scarcity, and simplicity.
You’re not educating. You’re not showcasing variety. You’re saying:
“4 hours left.”
“Ends at midnight.”
“Last chance before it’s gone.”
You can’t use the same email design for all three phases and expect to win. That’s what amateurs do.
The Perfect Black Friday Email Template Structure
Let’s talk structure. Here’s what top brands do — Macy’s, Wayfair, Nordstrom, etc.
They all follow this skeleton:
Hero Image – main offer and hook
Category Navigation – exploration and segmentation
Product Grid – high-intent clicks and conversion
Banners & Footer – value reinforcement and secondary CTAs
1. Hero Image: Your Click Magnet
This is the star of your email.
“Black Friday: Up to 80% Off”
“Biggest Black Friday Ever”
“Early Access Starts Now”
It’s above the fold on desktop and mobile. It does the heavy lifting of getting attention and clicks.
If you look at your data, your hero section almost always gets the most clicks. So treat it like prime real estate.
2. Navigation: Exploration Engine
This is where email design starts to separate adults from children.
Your nav might include:
Men | Women | Kids
Home | Tech | Gifts
Under $50 | Under $100 | Luxury
New In | Bestsellers | Gift Guide
This does 2 things:
It lets customers find what they want faster.
It gives you behavioral data based on click.
If someone clicks “Kids & Toys,” your next email should not be “Men’s Boots.”
It should be kids, toys, and gifts for kids. That’s how large retailers squeeze more revenue out of the same sends.
3. Product Grid: Conversion + Follow-Up Triggers
Under the nav, you show products:
Personalized based on browsing
Top sellers for that segment
Category-specific deals
When someone clicks a product:
They go to the PDP (not your homepage)
They’re more likely to convert
You automatically trigger browse-abandon flows
So one click does three things:
Shows interest in a category
Shows interest in a specific item
Activates automation
That’s how a strong email marketing agency thinks. Every click isn’t just traffic — it’s a trigger.
4. Banners & Footer: Value and Extras
This is where you reinforce the stuff that removes friction:
Free shipping
Free returns
“Order by Dec 20 to get it by the 24th”
Gift cards
Double points
Financing or “Buy Now, Pay Later”
These don’t need to be the star of the show, but they tip people over the edge. “Oh, I can return it easily? Okay, I’ll buy.”
This entire structure is email design with purpose. Every block is there to either:
Get a click
Tell you something about the customer
Or reduce friction to purchase
One Template Is Not Enough: The 3-Template System
Here’s where most brands mess it up:
They find a Black Friday email template they like…
…and they send basically the same thing 5 times in 5 days.
By day 3, the customer is numb.
The fix is simple: you don’t need 10 different templates. You need three:
Curiosity Template (Morning)
Curated Template (Midday)
Click Template (Night / Last Chance)
Template 1: Curiosity (AM Send)
Structure:
Hero image
Navigation
Dynamic products
Banners/footer
Goal:
Maximize exploration
Generate as many relevant clicks as possible
Collect data on what each customer cares about
This is where you say: “Here’s everything. Go explore.”
Template 2: Curated (Midday)
Structure:
Hero image
Products first (now more personalized)
Navigation under that
Banners/footer
Goal:
Show more of what they actually care about
Reflect back their behavior from the morning
Move from “browsing” to “deciding”
This feels more personal because it is. The algorithm (or your segmentation) is now curating offers based on their earlier behavior.
Template 3: Click (PM / Last Chance)
Structure:
Hero + CTA
Maybe a timer
Minimal distractions
Goal:
Get them back to the site
Turn “I should buy” into “I bought”
Use urgency and scarcity as levers
This is your “postcard” email — short, sharp, and to the point.
You can run this system:
On Black Friday
Again on Cyber Monday
Variations for Saturday/Sunday (Small Business Saturday, Cyber Sunday, etc.)
Same logic. Same psychology. Same structure.
But What If You Only Have a Few SKUs?
If you’re a young brand with 1–5 products, you’re not Macy’s. You don’t have 500,000 SKUs. That’s fine.
For you:
The hero/postcard email (the “Click” template) might do more of the heavy lifting.
You still use navigation, but it might be: “Bundle / Starter / Best Value” instead of categories.
You still want multiple click options (sizes, colors, bundles vs single products).
The principle remains the same:
More relevant click points = more data = more personalization = more revenue.
Even with a few SKUs, you can use smart email templates to move people through curiosity → curated → click.
What This Looks Like in Real Life
This isn’t theory.
One seven-figure home decor brand that implemented this:
Pulled their holiday demand forward into October
Grew email revenue 190% year-over-year in October
Grew another 260% year-over-year in November (powered by Black Friday & Cyber Monday)
Finished December up 90% year-over-year
They went from ~$300K in Q4 to ~$550K+ in Q4 largely by fixing email design, not just “sending more.”
How?
More click points
Better navigation
Personalized follow-ups
Proper Black Friday template sequencing
Not magic. Just math plus structure.
Key Takeaways: How to Actually Win Black Friday with Email
Let’s boil the episode down to the moves you should make.
1. Max Out Clicks, Not Sends
Don’t ask, “How many emails can we send?”
Ask:
“How many relevant clicks can we generate from each email?”
Use:
Hero + navigation + products + banners
Multiple click paths by category, color, size, use-case
Strong linking strategy (PDPs, not just homepages)
2. Match Email to Site
If your email promises “Black Friday 50% Off Home Décor,” and your landing page is a generic homepage… you’re killing conversion.
Mirror your email messaging on the page
Keep the same visuals, language, and offer
Make it dead simple to find what you teased in the email
Consistency converts.
3. Use the Right Template at the Right Time
Morning: Curiosity template → exploration and data
Midday: Curated template → personalized products and higher intent
Night: Click template → urgency and final push
Repeat for Cyber Monday. Adjust for Saturday/Sunday as needed.
Final Word
Most brands think Black Friday is about blasting harder.
The top brands know it’s about designing smarter.
It’s not just “do we have pretty emails?”
It’s “does our email design:
Personalize the experience?
Give us actionable data?
Move people through curiosity → curated → click?
Tie cleanly into our site and flows?”
If you’re working with an email marketing agency and they’re not talking to you about:
Click points
Navigation strategy
Product vs homepage linking
Template sequencing over the 5-day BFCM window
…you don’t have a strategy partner. You have a sender.
Black Friday is the Super Bowl of ecommerce.
You don’t win the Super Bowl with one play.
You win it with a playbook.
This is your playbook.
Now go rebuild your Black Friday email templates so they actually do their job — drive clicks, collect data, and convert like crazy.
Loved this blog post? Take one of these next steps:
Podcast: Play in new window | Download